Gerd-Jan van Wiggen: European banks caught between growth and regulation
Gerd-Jan van Wiggen: European banks caught between growth and regulation
This column was originally written in Dutch. This is an English translation.
By Gerd-Jan van Wiggen, Partner at Probability & Partners
Whilst the outside world is preoccupied with the saga surrounding whether or not Jensen Huang will remain as CEO of NVIDIA, my attention was drawn last week to one of the European Parliament’s daily bulletins.
The agenda of the Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs was announced in that document. My attention was drawn to the item entitled ‘Competitiveness of the banking sector in the European Union’. Here are a number of observations I would like to share, which are relevant to investors in banks.
Draghi
Let us first take a brief look back at Mario Draghi’s report, which has spurred a number of initiatives. In September 2024, he published his report on the future of European competitiveness. He begins by noting that Europe is lagging behind the United States in terms of GDP growth. Financing plays a part in this. When it comes to financing innovation, he notes that banks are not the right parties to provide this. More patient and risk-tolerant equity investors play a greater role in driving innovation. European banks can play a role in financing larger investments, but that role is limited by lower profitability, driven by higher costs and a smaller scale compared to US banks. The more limited scope for securitisation, the multitude of prudential laws and regulations, and the fragmented banking sector along national lines further constrain the banks’ capabilities.
Draghi proposes a number of concrete actions to improve the banking sector’s financing capacity. One area where progress is evident is the reform of securitisation legislation. The agreement of 21 October is a step in the right direction, although, in my view, more needs to be done on the part of potential investors to further stimulate this market.
A second area of focus is assessing whether prudential legislation and regulations are adequate. In this regard, we are seeing the EBA and the ECB take action, for example by simplifying reporting requirements somewhat. This reduces the costs associated with highly detailed data requests. Furthermore, there is a desire to simplify the capital stack, scrap the Pillar 2 requirement for the leverage ratio and review the deduction of software from CET1.
The final area – the completion of the Banking Union – is the most challenging, as it touches upon the sovereignty that countries hold over their own (systemically important) banks. See also the preliminary discussions surrounding UniCredit’s takeover bid for Commerzbank.
European Commission and European Parliament
In July, the European Commission published a paper entitled ‘Competitiveness of the Banking Sector and the Single Market in Banking’. Compared with the Draghi report, the focus appears to have shifted slightly more towards the banking sector. The Commission states that a competitive banking sector is important for financing growth, innovation and strategic priorities. It also states that the banking sector and the capital market are interdependent and must continue to develop in tandem. It also highlights the balance between growth and resilience, and between EU and national interests.
Parliament responded to this in September with a draft report. A number of points strike me in particular. The Commission’s analysis is acknowledged. Completing the Banking Union is a logical step. The report also recommends assigning the ESAs a secondary objective relating to Europe’s growth and competitiveness. Stability of the financial system remains the top priority, but with this addition, Parliament is choosing a different path for the future. The Commission itself does not make this proposal for the supervisory authorities and warns that simplification must not become deregulation.
A firm stance is taken on the use of AI, namely that banks should be encouraged to use AI in areas such as creditworthiness assessments, fraud prevention and risk management, and that innovative use cases can be tested without being classified in advance as high-risk under AI legislation. EU legislation must not act as an obstacle to the introduction of this technology.
This text by the rapporteur has led to 576 proposed amendments, which were published in October. This demonstrates that the process is thorough, but it does give me cause for concern that further discussions are still needed to reach a common position. The vote has now been postponed from 10 November to 1 December because the parties have not yet reached an agreement.
In substance, the debate centres on who is – or should be – (jointly) responsible for European competitiveness. The amendments also reveal that the debate surrounding speed versus prudence has not yet been resolved, particularly regarding the use of AI within banks.
What does this mean for investors?
My takeaway from the various documents is that two types of banks could benefit from the potential changes: banks that are required to hold relatively large amounts of capital and liquidity due to various national regimes, because they operate across borders, and those that manage to achieve economies of scale and cost efficiency, whether or not they use AI. The first group may appear attractive because they can return capital to investors, but this effect is one-off. In the longer term, the second group is more interesting, as they have a better chance of outperforming in a more competitive environment. Recent ECB research (Bank competitiveness and its role for monetary policy) also shows that a lower cost base, unlike lower capital requirements, has a measurable effect on competitiveness. The one-off effect is still some way off. The proposals are expected in the first quarter of 2027.
More columns by Gerd-Jan van Wiggen